space
space
Peshtigo Times
space
space
space
Perspectives
* Country Cousin
space
space
Sports Shorts
* Three Marinette Youth Wrestlers Compete at State
* Local Teams Compete in Oshkosh Indoor Track Meet
* Kelly Lake Sportsmen Walleye, Perch Stocking
* Warm Weather Spells Early Start for Local Softball
* Area Teams Kick Off Track Season

space
Peshtigo Fire
space
e-Edition
Now Available
For more information
click here
dot
THE CITY REBORN FROM THE ASHES OF AMERICA'S MOST DISASTROUS FOREST FIRE
space
dot
space

Congine, Village Crivitz Settle In Upside Down Flag Issue

According to news releases issued Thursday, Oct. 31, a case involving Vito Congine, Jr., the Village of Crivitz and display of an upside down flag has been settled, but details are not being released. Congine’s attorney, Chris Mueller, reportedly told a TV news station that terms of the settlement are confidential, but his client is pleased the matter has been resolved.

The issue began in 2008, when Congine began discussions with Crivitz Village Board about purchasing the former Pelkins Supermarket building in downtown Crivitz and converting it into an Italian Supper Club. Congine throughout the dispute has maintained the Village Board was at first very supportive, but then denied him the necessary liquor license after he had invested in the venture.

A 14-year veteran of the United States Marines, Congine began flying a United States flag upside down on the property at one of the main intersections in Crivitz. He explained at the time, and at later court proceedings, that an upside down flag is a universally recognized military symbol of distress, and he was flying it that way on his downtown Crivitz property to express distress over his treatment at the hands of the Crivitz Village Board.

The flag was flying upside down on July 4, 2009, while crowds were gathering for the big Fourth of July parade, but was taken down by authorities before the parade started and was returned on July 5.

Congine sued, saying his First Amendment free speech rights had been violated. Legal representatives for the village and Marinette County argued that the flag was taken to keep the peace during the Independence Day celebration.

Judge William Griesbach, in Green Bay’s Seventh Circuit of Wisconsin’s Eastern District Federal Court ruled on Tuesday, May 28, of this year, almost exactly four years after it became an issue in Crivitz, that Congine had a right to fly his United States flag upside down as a protest statement, and Crivitz police erred in confiscating the flag.

According to court documents, Crivitz Police Chief Mike Frievalt, after getting advice from Marinette County District Attorney Allen Brey, entered Congine’s property without a warrant and removed the flag. Frievalt maintained he had received many complaints from citizens, mainly members of the American Legion, and as the crowd gathered became afraid things would get out of control. He then, with the help of Officer Craig Kasten, removed the flag.

With the help of the American Civil Liberties Union, Congine later brought a lawsuit against the village and Brey. Congine charged his Constitutional rights were violated. In the 21-page May 28 ruling, Judge Griesbach agreed, at least in part. He found that the village had violated Congine’s rights, but decreed that Brey, because he provided only advice, had qualified immunity from liability.

Judge Griesbach wrote: “The court thus concludes that even assuming the facts set forth by the defendants are true, the intrusion upon Congine’s protected speech was not justified under the circumstances of this case.”

In an interview after the Federal Court ruling in May, Congine said that he and his wife, Trudy, had spent over $100,000 to remodel the building in downtown Crivitz before the village board reversed its previous encouragement and denied them a license.

Eventually they lost everything in bankruptcy, Congine said. He told the Peshtigo Times they were living in Naples, Fla. and did not intend returning to Wisconsin.

Since the Federal Court ruling in May, attorneys have been working on a settlement for damages and attorney fees. Mueller filed a letter with the court Thursday indicating settlement had been reached, but said details are confidential.

Crivitz Village Clerk Marilyn Padgett said the matter was covered by the village’s insurance policy, but any further details would need to come from Andrew Jones, the insurance company’s attorney for the case. She said the matter was referred to the insurance carrier from the beginning and she has not received any official word as yet on settlement details.


Recent stories, opinions and photos

Issue Date Department Headline
04-01-2015Perspectives
Country Cousin

04-01-2015Sports
Three Marinette Youth Wrestlers Compete at State

04-01-2015Sports
Local Teams Compete in Oshkosh Indoor Track Meet

04-01-2015Sports
Kelly Lake Sportsmen Walleye, Perch Stocking

04-01-2015Sports
Warm Weather Spells Early Start for Local Softball

04-01-2015


04-01-2015Perspectives
From our readers

04-01-2015Perspectives
Tales from the old-timer

04-01-2015Obituaries
Lee G. Walcheske

04-01-2015Obituaries
Arlene M. Techert

04-01-2015Obituaries
Mary J. Sievert

04-01-2015Obituaries
Audrey A. Renner

04-01-2015Obituaries
Bentley C. Plosczynski

04-01-2015Obituaries
Jo Ann Kozlowski

04-01-2015Obituaries
Alice Kouski

04-01-2015Obituaries
Linda D. Knutson

04-01-2015Obituaries
Kevin Kirkland

04-01-2015Obituaries
Roy W. Kamin

04-01-2015Obituaries
Guy H. Kallenbach

04-01-2015Obituaries
Karen L. Henne

04-01-2015Obituaries
Marion E. Hartman

04-01-2015Obituaries
Thomas C. Christ

04-01-2015Obituaries
Bob Talbot

04-01-2015Obituaries
Janet E. Smith

04-01-2015Obituaries
Lavona M. Revall

04-01-2015Obituaries
Anton F. Olszewski

04-01-2015Obituaries
Wallace L. Maske

04-01-2015Obituaries
Shirley Marquardt

04-01-2015Obituaries
Robert D. Legault

04-01-2015Obituaries
Robert Le Hew

04-01-2015Obituaries
Debbie A. Konop

04-01-2015Obituaries
Catherine R. Klepp

04-01-2015Obituaries
Marcella M. Kiszely

04-01-2015Obituaries
Shirley A. Imig

04-01-2015Obituaries
Michael D. Gilkes

04-01-2015Obituaries
Sister Marjorie Fabry

04-01-2015Obituaries
Mieczyslaw Dolecki

04-01-2015Obituaries
Sallie A. Davis

04-01-2015Obituaries
Eleanor C. Christnovich

04-01-2015Community - Wausaukee
3 on 3 Fun Day at Wausaukee Apr. 4

04-01-2015Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Library To Host Author

04-01-2015Community - Wausaukee
Silver Cliff Fire, Rescue To Offer Scholarship

04-01-2015Community - Wausaukee
Cameras Topic of Training Class

04-01-2015Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Marks Legion Birthday

04-01-2015Community - Crivitz
Over 350 Compete at Crivitz Music Fest

04-01-2015Community - Crivitz
CBA/CRA Annual Banquet at Rene’s

04-01-2015Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Flea, Farmers Market on Thursdays

04-01-2015Community - Coleman
Author Speaks at Coleman Library

04-01-2015Community - Coleman
Coleman Music Students Score at M&O Festival

04-01-2015Community - Coleman
Coleman Village Board April 6

04-01-2015Community - Coleman
Register for Coleman T-Ball

04-01-2015News
CBA Easter Egg Hunt is April 4

04-01-2015News
Appreciation Fish Fry for Landowners

04-01-2015News
Empty Bowl To Benefit Food Pantry

04-01-2015News
Peace Church Rummage Sale

04-01-2015Front Page
HONORED

04-01-2015Front Page
Voters to Fill City, Town, Village School Board Posts on April 7

04-01-2015Front Page
DOT Continues To Seek Safer Hwy. 41 Crossing

04-01-2015Front Page
Hwy. 141 Detour From Beaver To Wausaukee

04-01-2015Front Page
To Collect DNA Samples at Arrest

03-25-2015Sports
Area Teams Kick Off Track Season

03-25-2015Sports
Pillath Voted Top M&O Wrestler

03-25-2015Sports
UW-Buccaneers Claim Post-Season Honors

03-25-2015Sports
Ranger Duo Share M&O MVP

03-25-2015Perspectives
Country Cousin

03-25-2015Perspectives
From our readers

03-25-2015Perspectives
Tales from the old-timer

03-25-2015Obituaries
Leonard Walters

03-25-2015Obituaries
Robert Talbot

03-25-2015Obituaries
William H. Myers

03-25-2015Obituaries
Susan A. Mejer

03-25-2015Obituaries
Eric P. Marquis

03-25-2015Obituaries
Joseph D. Kubasik

03-25-2015Obituaries
Elmer R. Knutson

03-25-2015Obituaries
Margaret E. Jamison

03-25-2015Obituaries
Vernon L. Hollister

03-25-2015Obituaries
Edward F. Harris

03-25-2015Obituaries
Dennis C. Hanson

03-25-2015Obituaries
Margaret Gorski

03-25-2015Obituaries
Daniel M. Carlson

03-25-2015Obituaries
Robert J. Bell

03-25-2015Obituaries
George W. Adams

03-25-2015Obituaries
Minnie A. Swanson

03-25-2015Obituaries
Charlotte T. Robison

03-25-2015Obituaries
Gladys M. Peters

03-25-2015Obituaries
Gerald J. Knutson

03-25-2015Obituaries
Ken Jendrusiak

03-25-2015Obituaries
Louis C. Hellermann

03-25-2015Obituaries
Larry D. Godson

03-25-2015Obituaries
Scottie J. Fifarek

03-25-2015Obituaries
Daniel G. Diercks

03-25-2015Obituaries
Ethel J. Bryngelson

03-25-2015Obituaries
Esther M. Borths

03-25-2015Community - Wausaukee
Winners in Wagner Benefit Card Party

03-25-2015Community - Wausaukee
Authors To Visit Wausaukee Library

03-25-2015Community - Wausaukee
T/Wausaukee Against County Assessing, Okay Variance

03-25-2015Community - Wausaukee
Wagner OK Purchase Of New Tender Truck

03-25-2015Community - Crivitz
Hundreds Attend Rural Life Day in Crivitz

03-25-2015Community - Crivitz
Walleye Spawning Project on Lake Noquebay

03-25-2015Community - Crivitz
CBA/CRA Annual Banquet at Rene’s

03-25-2015Community - Crivitz
CBA Easter Egg Hunt is April 4

03-25-2015Community - Coleman
Library Lists Month’s Events

03-25-2015Community - Coleman
Annual Auction at Faith Christian School

03-25-2015Community - Coleman
Coleman-Pound Lions Brunch Palm Sunday

03-25-2015Community - Coleman
New Church To Open in Pound

03-25-2015News
Klondike Little League Signup

03-25-2015News
Pembine Craft Sales April 11

03-25-2015News
Lena Pathfinders Rummage Sale

03-25-2015Front Page
BARN FIRE

03-25-2015Front Page
3 Killed In Bank Robbery Spree

03-25-2015Front Page
Coleman School Tables High School Remodeling

03-25-2015Front Page
Peshtigo Persons of Year Banquet March 29

03-25-2015Front Page
CJCC Seeks Grant For Local Drug Treatment

03-18-2015Community - Coleman
Coleman Church Fish Fry Mar. 20

03-18-2015Sports
No Trolling Rule For Fishing Opener

03-18-2015Sports
Wausaukee Lions Bowlers Host Over 225 Games, 600 Series

03-18-2015Sports
40th State Girls Basketball Tourney Crowns Five Champs

03-18-2015Sports
WIAA Boys 100th State Basketball Tournament

03-18-2015Perspectives
Country Cousin

03-18-2015Perspectives
From our readers

03-18-2015Perspectives
Tales from the old-timer

03-18-2015Obituaries
Robert A. Van Norman, Sr.

03-18-2015Obituaries
Steven J, Sharpe

03-18-2015Obituaries
Linda J. Porter

03-18-2015Obituaries
Frank A. Peterson

03-18-2015Obituaries
Helen L. Peterson

03-18-2015Obituaries
Michael D. Olsen

03-18-2015Obituaries
Rev. Dr. Howard E. Nelson

03-18-2015Obituaries
Fred Kuhnle

03-18-2015Obituaries
Joyce Kleinke

03-18-2015Obituaries
Kenneth C. Hult

03-18-2015Obituaries
Sandra L. Heck

03-18-2015Obituaries
Robert W. Hafeman

03-18-2015Obituaries
Claryce M. Finger

03-18-2015Obituaries
Gail Marie Becker

03-18-2015Obituaries
Jean Ann Stocker

03-18-2015Obituaries
Scott E. Seymour

03-18-2015Obituaries
Thomas A. Schloegel

03-18-2015Obituaries
John A. Payant

03-18-2015Obituaries
Dorraine Pantti

03-18-2015Obituaries
Felicia A. Klatkiewicz

03-18-2015Obituaries
Kenneth P. Herlache

03-18-2015Obituaries
Alice M. Hansen

03-18-2015Obituaries
Margaret Greening

03-18-2015Obituaries
Larry Curran

03-18-2015Obituaries
Clark P. Clermont, Sr.

03-18-2015Obituaries
Margaret M. Berger

03-18-2015Obituaries
Robert Bence

03-18-2015Obituaries
Myrtle E. Beaupre

03-18-2015Obituaries
Walter S. Banko


space
Peshtigo Times
WEB Poll!
Do you think the Badgers will win the National Championship?
space Yes
No
Undecided
space
TO VOTE CLICK
YES, NO or UNDECIDED

Suggest a Question
space .
space
FRONT
space
.
space
CLASSIFIEDS
space
.
space
COMMUNITY
space
.
space
GUEST BOOK
space
.
space
NEWS
space
.
space
OBITS
space
.
space
PERSPECTIVES
space
.
space
SPORTS
space
.
space
SUBSCRIBE
space
.
space
.
space
PESHTIGO FIRE
space
.
space
CUSTOM PRINTING
space
.
space
TIMES' SAVER
space
.
space
Click for Peshtigo, Wisconsin Forecast
FORECAST
space
Quick...
News or Ad Search
Enter News key words.
Enter Ad key words.



Peshtigo Times
841 Maple St
PO Box 187
Peshtigo, WI 54157
Phone: 715-582-4541
Email:
News@
PeshtigoTimes.com

space
Fax: 715-582-4662
© 2000-2015
All right reserved
space
Powered by
WEB Media
Interactive
COMMUNITY
WEB sites