space
space
Peshtigo Times
space
space
space
Perspectives
* Country Cousin
space
space
Sports Shorts
* National Walleye Tour Opens on Green Bay at Oconto July 23-24
* Red Wave Get Back to Winning Ways; Drop Coleman/Bark River
* Menominee Battles Hard For 4-1 Week
* Red Wave Win Streak Continues; Move to 8-0
* Reinhard of Marinette in UW-W Hall of Fame

space
Peshtigo Fire
space
e-Edition
Now Available
For more information
click here
dot
THE CITY REBORN FROM THE ASHES OF AMERICA'S MOST DISASTROUS FOREST FIRE
space
dot
space

DNR, PFAS Listening Session Raises Concerns

Issue Date: January 30, 2020

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) Listening Session 5 on Wednesday, Jan. 15 was an update of who is doing what and the status of the investigation and clean up.

Christine Haag, Bureau Director Division of Environmental Management Remediation and Redevelopment of the DNR, began the session explaining the roles and responsibilities of the entities involved. Anytime a situation such as a contamination occurs, State Law dictates that the responsible party, in this case, Tyco, Johnson Control (JCI), has to immediately report the situation, secondly they need to take steps to restore the environment to its natural state, create a plan to follow and then recommend to the DNR their work plan for them to agree or disagree with their actions.

The DNR's role is to make sure the responsible party is in compliance with the law and then reviews all the technical information received from the offender. The DNR is then responsible for public participation and notification of what happened and then work with health agencies, local governments and other stakeholders in the community.

The responsible party is then responsible for openly reporting the contamination, do site investigation to determine the intensity of the contamination. They then need to take immediate, interim and remedial actions to reach a long term solution and satisfy the long term obligations.

There are four PFAS open site investigations including Tyco/JCI Fire Technology Center, Tyco/JCI Stanton Street, ChemDesign and the City of Marinette Biosolids land-spreading fields with JCI/Tyco being the responsible party resulting in several impacted communities.

Haag said to the audience, "Tyco/JCI owes a number of reports and things to you and to the DNR". A meeting was held Jan. 23 of all the expectations from Tyco/JCI, including drinking water sampling, test site sampling, well and biosolids testing.

Potentially Responsible Party (RSP) letters were sent out to Tyco/JCI and ChemDesign requesting information and testing of the City of Peshtigo Biosolids land-spreading fields, JCI/Tyco Woleski Road warehouse/ test facility and JCI/Tyco Pine Street test facility in Peshtigo.

Based on recent homeowner sampling data, DNR evaluation of groundwater data and other site investigation data, there are approximately 10 to 12 home owners outside of the original suggested affected area that are now contaminated and are above the recommended safe contaminant level of 20 Parts Per Trillion (PPT). The DNR has instructed Tyco to expand their study area and contact everyone in the expanded area of the need to get their wells tested. Tyco needs to sample the drinking water and proceed accordingly with drinking water systems for residents.

Tyco/JCI was contacted by the DNR to resample and provide drinking water to these residents and they denied to do what was asked of them. The DNR is working with the Department of Justice (DOJ) for the next steps to take if Tyco/JCI does not proceed accordingly. The DNR will then step in and do the testing and provide safe drinking water to the residents until there is no more money to spend and Tyco/JCR will be billed by the DNR.

Clara Jeong, PHD Toxicologist, Wisconsin Department of Health Services, explained there is a lot of work to be done on what effects PFAS has on our health. Work needs to be done in evaluating literature to determine safe levels in water, which is now 20 PPT; Identify pathways at specific sites and how much exposure do we get through these pathways; Make recommendations to prevent or reduce exposure and educate the affected communities and local health professionals about site contamination and potential health effects.

In various studies of several different diseases and health issues, there was probable association with PFAS exposure and increased or high cholesterol, preeclampsia, pregnancy induced hypertension, thyroid disease, ulcerative colitis, reduced antibody response, decreased fertility in women and testis and kidney cancers. At this time, we don't know how much PFAS has to be in our blood to cause these health affects.

Jeong said, "Things we have learned about PFAS are they can stay in the body for many years, they can cross the placenta during pregnancy and they can pass through breast milk. Major exposure pathways to PFAS include drinking contaminated water, eating fish caught from contaminated water, accidentally swallowing contaminated soil or dust and eating food that was packaged in material that contains PFAS.

The session then moved into the question and answer portion of the meeting with various people in the audience asking questions on various topics.

If a contaminant is in a persons blood and they donate their blood are we spreading the PFAS to other people? DNR response: It is true if you take out blood from one person and put in another, overall, it will transfer, but think about the volume. The PFAS will transfer, but the other person will not have the same level. At the blood banks, the blood is diluted and pooled so the amount that is transferred is minimal and has never been an issue.

If the DNR only has so much funding and JCI is not willing to cover costs and testing, why are we not holding them liable? If I contaminated my neighbors property I would be liable and probably sitting in prison. DNR response: The DNR received money we can spend in emergency situations or ask the responsible party to address and if they decline, they still need to take care of the people. JCI needs to come forward with the resources, provide safe water and do cleanup. The DNR is holding them responsible and this is our direction to follow the law and do the cleanup. When they fail we go through the enforcement process and they are referred to the DOJ and they will evaluate where we go from there. Just because we take emergency action doesn't imply we are not holding them responsible. Tyco will be charged back for the money we spend on the cleanup as well.

Is anyone doing any blood testing to get a baseline level? DNR response: The diagnosis is limited and everyone has PFAS in their blood with all the products this contaminant was used in. It is very hard to define where the contaminant came from. Senator Dave Hansen did recommend blood testing for employees of Tyco and the people in the affected area.

Is the Bay safe to swim in or is that an issue? DNR response: That is minor exposure. Tyco/JCI did submit a work plan to do a study and the results will be available in Spring. We are short staffed with not enough funding. Any proposed legislation you can support to get more funding and authority will help us in doing our jobs. There are a couple of pieces of legislation out there including the CLEAR act. This would do many things and give us additional financial resources and staffing.

Tyco/JCI refused to help in testing outside of the affected area, that is unacceptable, are there any plans to continue testing beyond the affected area? DNR response: Tyco/JCI delineated an area by the testing center and we will be asking them to do testing in other areas. We have already asked them to do testing of the biosolids and will be meeting in a couple of weeks to discuss the boundary area.

A young man in the audience announced he had several bouts with testicular cancer and growing up lived in the area of contamination. He stated, three out of 75 males in this area get testicular cancer, that is 10 times the national rate. It was confirmed that PFAS is associated with testicular and kidney cancers. Part of me knows there was something in the water, but the odds are in our favor, "JCI/Tyco will be held responsible"!

Muriel Carter, a Town of Peshtigo resident commented, "Thank You for continuing to come here. We appreciate you giving us updates, spending the time and answering our questions. Is there a way to assure the DNR gets more resources to continue"? DNR response: There will be a cost recovery from Tyco/JCI but it comes down to the cost benefit and whether the public can advocate for the needed legislation.

The DNR ended with advising they will be collecting data on deer at the Tyco/JCI testing sight. We are working on doing some studies on fish in the area waters and we will have data in the upcoming months. Haag asked for input of what the public wants to do from here, if they should continue to do monthly listening sessions or bi-monthly. Where do you want to go from here? Haag stated, "Even if we are not with you on a monthly basis, we are always there for you".

We want to have open and ongoing communication, ask questions, give feedback and let us know what topics you want to hear about by calling our message line at 888-626-3244 or emailing us at DNRJCIPFAS@wisconsin.gov You can also get answers to frequently asked questions (FAQs) on the website: https://dnr.wi.gov/topic/contaminants or do a search of PFAS Peshtigo and Marinette.

The last of the scheduled Listening Sessions will be Wednesday, Feb. 19 starting at 6 p.m.


Recent stories, opinions and photos

Issue Date Department Headline
07-08-2020Community - Coleman
Community Has Food Pantry Lists Guidelines

07-08-2020Community - Coleman
Seth Seefeldt Wins $8,000 Georgia-Pacific Scholarship

07-08-2020Community - Crivitz
Successful Crivitz July 4th Parade

07-08-2020Community - Crivitz
Chelsea Michalski on Dubuque Dean's List

07-08-2020Community - Crivitz
CBA Area Wide Rummage Sale

07-08-2020Community - Crivitz
Art in the Park at Crivitz Aug. 8

07-08-2020Community - Wausaukee
Verdegan's "Racing in the 906" Book Signing July 12

07-08-2020Community - Wausaukee
Amberg Legion Post 428, Auxiliary Meet July 10

07-08-2020Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Celebrates 4th With Parade, Fireworks

07-08-2020Obituaries
Mary P. Aderman

07-08-2020Obituaries
Gary E. Berger

07-08-2020Obituaries
Loretta H. Dyer

07-08-2020Obituaries
Roger L. Enderby

07-08-2020Obituaries
Ruth M. Gravelle

07-08-2020Obituaries
Troy R. Hruska

07-08-2020Obituaries
Debra L. Johnson

07-08-2020Obituaries
Anita Yvonne Kaus 

07-08-2020Obituaries
Rodney Kopish Sr.

07-08-2020Obituaries
Lou Ellen M. Krueger

07-08-2020Obituaries
Harlan D. Linderoth

07-08-2020Obituaries
Mark R. Marineau

07-08-2020Obituaries
Harriet E. Mielke

07-08-2020Obituaries
Ralph Orlando

07-08-2020Obituaries
Patricia Picard

07-08-2020Obituaries
Carter J. Shea

07-08-2020Obituaries
Daniel C. Schaut

07-08-2020Obituaries
Fred C. Tessmer

07-08-2020Obituaries
Veronica A. Theis

07-08-2020Perspectives
Country Cousin

07-08-2020Perspectives
From My Window

07-08-2020Perspectives
From our readers

07-08-2020Sports
National Walleye Tour Opens on Green Bay at Oconto July 23-24

07-08-2020Sports
Red Wave Get Back to Winning Ways; Drop Coleman/Bark River

07-01-2020Front Page
Marinette Marine Employees, Ships Draw Praise From President Trump

07-01-2020Front Page
Camping Outing Ends In Tragedy

07-01-2020Front Page
Crivitz Board Votes To Open Indoor Facilities

07-01-2020Front Page
2020 Marinette County Fair Aug. 27- 30 At Wausaukee

07-01-2020Community - Coleman
No Coleman Village Board Meet July 6

07-01-2020Community - Coleman
Cougar Booster Club Cancels Annual Banquet

07-01-2020Community - Coleman
Five Area Fire Departments Respond to Patz Pallet Fire

07-01-2020Community - Coleman
Set Coleman Graduation July 11; Open Outdoor School Facilities

07-01-2020Community - Coleman


07-01-2020Community - Crivitz
Loomis Post 476 Cancels Meeting

07-01-2020Community - Wausaukee
Blood Drive at Silver Cliff

07-01-2020Community - Wausaukee
First Presbyterian Churches Open July 5

07-01-2020Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee/Silver Cliff Blood Drive July 6th

07-01-2020Obituaries
Margaret M. Callies

07-01-2020Obituaries
Donna R. Cherry

07-01-2020Obituaries
Janette Enix

07-01-2020Obituaries
Lila M. Guse

07-01-2020Obituaries
Marilyn J. Krueger

07-01-2020Obituaries
Joyce C. Larsen

07-01-2020Obituaries
Angeline I. Mazur

07-01-2020Obituaries
Phyllis M. Meles

07-01-2020Obituaries
Mary C. Olson

07-01-2020Obituaries
Richard A. Phillips

07-01-2020Obituaries
Jean M. Pleshek

07-01-2020Obituaries
Joseph A. Policello

07-01-2020Obituaries
George F. Seymour

07-01-2020Obituaries
John M. Steinhofer

07-01-2020Obituaries
Philip R. Tetting 

07-01-2020Perspectives
Country Cousin

07-01-2020Perspectives
From My Window

07-01-2020Perspectives
From our readers

07-01-2020Sports
Menominee Battles Hard For 4-1 Week

06-24-2020
Work Begins on Peshtigo's New Fish Viewing Platform

06-24-2020Front Page
Trish Schutte Named New Middle Inlet Clerk/Treasurer

06-24-2020Front Page
Peshtigo Graduation to Include Parade on July 2

06-24-2020Front Page
Crivitz School Board Votes To Open Outdoor Areas, Keep Buildings Closed

06-24-2020Front Page
Peshtigo Plan Commission To Consider Zoning Variances

06-24-2020Community - Coleman
Coleman Fire Cancels Picnic, Raffles Still On

06-24-2020Community - Coleman
Coleman High School Cancels Class Reunion

06-24-2020Community - Coleman
Coleman Police Release Sex Offender Notice

06-24-2020Community - Coleman
Coleman School District Office Closed July 1-6

06-24-2020Community - Crivitz
Crowley Re-elected as Legion Commander

06-24-2020Community - Crivitz
De Smidt's Awards Golf Memberships

06-24-2020Community - Wausaukee
Athelstane FD Raffle Drawing Party July 11

06-24-2020Community - Wausaukee
Legion Auxiliary Unit 66 Discuss Chili Fest Sept. 26

06-24-2020Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Enterprises Gets M&M Area Grant

06-24-2020Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Organizations Sponsor July 4 Festivities

06-24-2020Obituaries
Wana M. Allard

06-24-2020Obituaries
Laura J. Cairns

06-24-2020Obituaries
Patricia D. Couvillion

06-24-2020Obituaries
Lowell S. Duenweg

06-24-2020Obituaries
Alois L. Geiger III

06-24-2020Obituaries
Joyce D. Hilliard

06-24-2020Obituaries
Gretchen A. Keiler

06-24-2020Obituaries
William H. Keller III

06-24-2020Obituaries
Ladonna A. List

06-24-2020Obituaries
Gerald A. Monnette

06-24-2020Obituaries
Gloria L. Mueller

06-24-2020Obituaries
Wilda A. Olson

06-24-2020Obituaries
Jerome D. Rasner

06-24-2020Obituaries
Eleanor Raygo

06-24-2020Obituaries
Gerhard Rosenlund, Jr.

06-24-2020Obituaries
Robert G. Schacht

06-24-2020Obituaries
Paul K. Witzke

06-24-2020Obituaries
Zach R. Zahn

06-24-2020Perspectives
Country Cousin

06-24-2020Perspectives
From My Window

06-24-2020Perspectives
From our readers

06-24-2020Sports
Red Wave Win Streak Continues; Move to 8-0

06-24-2020Sports
Reinhard of Marinette in UW-W Hall of Fame

06-24-2020Sports
WI-DNR's Summer Natural Resources Magazine Released

06-24-2020Sports
Northern Zone Smallmouth Bass Season Opens June 20

06-17-2020Front Page
Crash Scene

06-17-2020Front Page
Marinette School District Moves Toward $31 Million Referendum

06-17-2020Front Page
Hale Road Is Re-Opened Road Repairs Postponed

06-17-2020Front Page
Peshtigo Graduation Option To Include Parade On July 2

06-17-2020Front Page
Crivitz's "Jerry the Barber" Retires After 66 Years in Barber Business

06-17-2020Community - Crivitz
Benefit Golf Scramble Aug. 18

06-17-2020Community - Crivitz
Bible Studies by Northwood's Church

06-17-2020Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Museum Hosts Flea, Farmers Market

06-17-2020Community - Crivitz
Crivitz School Receives Funds For Book Giveaway Program

06-17-2020Community - Wausaukee
Athelstane Volunteer Fire Department Receives Grant

06-17-2020Community - Wausaukee
Warming Building for Wagner Recycling Discussed

06-17-2020Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Road Crew Constructs Hall Ramp

06-17-2020Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee to Hold Parade and Fireworks

06-17-2020Obituaries
Harriet V. Barley

06-17-2020Obituaries
Robert L. Boulanger

06-17-2020Obituaries
Judy A. Calhoun

06-17-2020Obituaries
Helen M. Carlson

06-17-2020Obituaries
Ronald J. Chevalier

06-17-2020Obituaries
Daniel H. Ellis

06-17-2020Obituaries
Barbara J. Gillis

06-17-2020Obituaries
Bernhardt M. Hogstrom

06-17-2020Obituaries
James R. Houle

06-17-2020Obituaries
Barbara J. Johnston

06-17-2020Obituaries
Robert A. Kass

06-17-2020Obituaries
Allen E. Kopczynski

06-17-2020Obituaries
Kenneth J. Krouth

06-17-2020Obituaries
Roy Marquardt

06-17-2020Obituaries
Josephine M. Massey

06-17-2020Obituaries
Dorothy Mertens

06-17-2020Obituaries
James Mueller

06-17-2020Obituaries
Donald L. Patterson

06-17-2020Obituaries
Diana Philippi

06-17-2020Obituaries
Debra Pogrant

06-17-2020Obituaries
Kathryn A. Richardson

06-17-2020Obituaries
Dolores M. Rouse

06-17-2020Obituaries
Robert D. Saxton

06-17-2020Obituaries
Judy A. Staffin

06-17-2020Obituaries
Wendy Strem

06-17-2020Obituaries
 Michael G. Van Mun

06-17-2020Obituaries
Mary Ann Wilde

06-17-2020Perspectives
Country Cousin

06-17-2020Perspectives
From My Window

06-17-2020Perspectives
From Our Readers

06-17-2020Sports
"Play Ball" Red Wave 3-0 to Start Season

06-17-2020Sports
Norway Speedway Releases It's Updated 2020 Season Schedule


space
Peshtigo Times
WEB Poll!
Do you wear a mask when you go out in public to prevent the spread of Covid19?
space Yes
No
Undecided
space
TO VOTE CLICK
YES, NO or UNDECIDED

Suggest a Question
space .
space
FRONT
space
.
space
CLASSIFIEDS
space
.
space
COMMUNITY
space
.
space
GUEST BOOK
space
.
space
NEWS
space
.
space
OBITS
space
.
space
PERSPECTIVES
space
.
space
SPORTS
space
.
space
SUBSCRIBE
space
.
space
.
space
PESHTIGO FIRE
space
.
space
CUSTOM PRINTING
space
.
space
TIMES' SAVER
space
.
space
Click for Peshtigo, Wisconsin Forecast
FORECAST
space
Quick...
News or Ad Search
Enter News key words.
Enter Ad key words.



Peshtigo Times
841 Maple St
PO Box 187
Peshtigo, WI 54157
Phone: 715-582-4541
Email:
News@
PeshtigoTimes.com

space
Fax: 715-582-4662
© 2000-2020
All right reserved
space
Powered by
WEB Media
Interactive
COMMUNITY
WEB sites