space
space
Peshtigo Times
space
space
space
Perspectives
* Country Cousin
space
space
Sports Shorts
* 2 Crivitz Youth Compete in PPK at Green Bay Dec. 4
* Area Girls' Basketball
* Area Boys' Basketball
* MHSAA State Championship
* Coach Motkowski Ready to Unleash "Dogs in '16-൙

space
Peshtigo Fire
space
e-Edition
Now Available
For more information
click here
dot
THE CITY REBORN FROM THE ASHES OF AMERICA'S MOST DISASTROUS FOREST FIRE
space
dot
space
020514ROBBERY.jpg

captured—1956 photo of law enforcement officers and posse members capturing suspected Peshtigo National Bank robbers Harold Vaughn and Albert James Vito. The pair were captured in the Peshtigo Harbor Area. Vito is the robber who shot Yvonne (Valliere) Sielaff.

Woman Shot In ‘56 Bank Robbery Dies Saturday

Yvonne M. (Valliere) Sielaff, 85, of Menomonee Falls, former Peshtigo resident, died of natural causes Saturday, Feb. 1, in Menomonee Falls, still carrying a bullet in her jaw since the May 21, 1956 robbery of the Peshtigo National Bank where she had worked for many years with her husband, Robert. It was the first bank robbery in Peshtigo and in Marinette County.

The .22 caliber bullet was never removed from her jaw for medical reasons but it was closely watched by her dentist through the years. The bullet may now be recovered after cremation.

It was a sunny Monday morning as the four bank employees were working. Mrs. Sielaff was sitting at a table behind a counter, her husband was at the counter, and Jeannette Rhode and Oscar Bartels, cashier, were on the telephone. It was about 9:58 a.m. when the two bandits, Harold Vaughn, 17, formerly of Porterfield, and Albert James Vito, 21, entered wearing jackets over their colored shirts and sun glasses which they had just purchased at Driscoll Service Station. They had just bought $1.50 worth of gas at DeHart Gas Station.

Vaughn walked to the middle of the three windows where Robert Sielaff was checking a deposit left several minutes earlier by the bank president, Earl DeHart Sr. The other bandit, Vito, occupied a position about eight feet behind Vaughn and had a commanding view of the entire bank. Three .22 caliber bullets were fired. One bullet, allegedly fired by Vaughn, was aimed at Bartels, but struck the leg of a chair. The other two were alleged to have been fired by Vito, one in the direction of Robert Sielaff and the other at his wife. The bullet fired at Mrs. Sielaff went through a half inch plywood panel and may have ricocheted off a coin holder behind the panel, striking her in the front jaw. The bandits were in the bank for only about one minute.

Mrs. Sielaff slumped to the floor in a small pool of blood and was rushed to Marinette General Hospital by her husband and Earl DeHart Jr. She remained in the hospital for several days but the bullet was not removed.

The two bandits left the bank in about one minute with $1,045 and went to their parked vehicle on West Front St., one block away. It was a 1956 red and yellow Mercury convertible. Prior to the robbery, the vehicle had been noticed by several city residents and police traveling around the city who became suspicious and wrote down the license number. Police Officer Stewart Jarvis was one of the persons who copied the license number when he observed the pair sleeping at Badger Park.

The robbers then sped down West Front St. heading south and apparently were unfamiliar with the area as they ended up in the Peshtigo Harbor Swamps, six miles south of the scene of their crime. Within minutes of the robbery, a search began and they were captured by a posse of over 200 individuals within 2 1/2 hours at the Peshtigo Harbor. The robbery happened close to 10 a.m. and by 12:30 p.m. they were handcuffed by Sheriff Marriner Kohlman.

The posse and law enforcement response drew praise from Sheriff Kohlman who issued a statement expressing appreciation to the posse and law enforcement officers from Marinette, Menominee, Oconto, Peshtigo and sheriff officers from the counties of Menominee, Mich., Oconto, Brown, and Shawano as well as State Police, DNR wardens and pilots Capt. Ted Axtell of the Civil Air Patrol and Earl DeHart who assisted in the search.

The car of the two bank robbers was spotted around noon from the air in the Peshtigo Harbor Area by Capt. Axtell of the Civil Air Patrol. Law enforcement officers were already in the nearby area, but Axtell had no radio and had to land his plane on a roadway to inform officers.

Meanwhile, Sheriff Kohlman and five members of the posse were creeping up on the robbers who were lying exhausted on a small strip of land separated from the mainland by about 50 feet of water. Kohlman fired a shot and warned the robbers to surrender. He then ordered them to take off their trousers and to wade across the water to him. At the same time, the pair were unaware that a boatload of posse members was approaching them from the rear. When captured the pair had $990 and admitted losing part of the loot in their attempted get-away.

Under questioning, the pair admitted the bank robbery and also their first intention was to rob the Peshtigo State Bank but were deterred by the number of people in that bank. They also admitted to entering the Marinette Sporting Goods Store in Marinette on Saturday, two days before the bank robbery, to steal the three .22 caliber guns they used in the robbery. When captured, the pair had no guns and told authorities they had thrown the weapons away.

Reason for the robbery was to obtain money to pay off a $3,600 mortgage on the car owned by Vaughn.

On Tuesday, May 22, the pair were handed over to the FBI since a national bank had been robbed. They appeared before U.S. Commissioner John Reynolds Jr., who set bond at $50,000 each. The pair were then transferred to the U.S. District Court in Milwaukee.

Vito was charged with violating the federal bank robbery act and Vaughn, because of his age was held under the federal juvenile delinquency act.

There were several interesting sidelights to the capture. The robbers headed towards the bay believing they could take a side road over to Marinette, only the Peshtigo River was in the way and the only bridge was in Peshtigo, and then drive up into Michigan. Instead they ended up in the yard of Tom Motkowski’s Fish Haven where they turned around and headed back towards Peshtigo. At the Hale Road School, they turned east on a sand road which led to the Peshtigo Harbor where they followed a car driven by Howard Brabender Jr., Peshtigo, who was going fishing at the harbor.

The pair turned around and drove as far as the Thompson Red Barn and attempted to park their vehicle in the barn. However the barn was not suitable and then drove into the marsh in an attempt to hide the vehicle after hearing a description of their vehicle and license number on the car radio.

Meanwhile, Brabender was returning to Peshtigo from fishing when he noticed the partially hidden car. He considered stopping to help pull the vehicle out but seeing neither of the men, continued on his way home. Upon arriving home, he was informed by his mother of the robbery who gave him a description of the get-away car. Brabender then went to the Peshtigo Police station and notified authorities of what he had seen.


Recent stories, opinions and photos

Issue Date Department Headline
11-30-2016Obituaries
Brielle R. Beres

11-30-2016Obituaries
Melvin J. Blohowiak

11-30-2016Obituaries
Sharon A. Bogner 

11-30-2016Obituaries
Robert Chaltry

11-30-2016Obituaries
Shirley G. Collins

11-30-2016Obituaries
Carol Jean Downing

11-30-2016Obituaries
Katherine L. Duaime

11-30-2016Obituaries
Orven L. Fabry

11-30-2016Obituaries
James Haban

11-30-2016Obituaries
Leonard Jarosz

11-30-2016Obituaries
Robert Magnin

11-30-2016Obituaries
Lela M. McTrusty

11-30-2016Obituaries
Richard E. Neely

11-30-2016Community - Coleman
Village Board Meets Dec. 5

11-30-2016Obituaries
Myra I. Orlando

11-30-2016Community - Coleman
Youth Wrestling Sign Up Dec. 1st

11-30-2016Obituaries
Bernadine M. Pietrek

11-30-2016Obituaries
Elaine H. Rathjen

11-30-2016Community - Coleman
Free Health Event at Coleman PK Fit

11-30-2016Obituaries
James L. Stillman

11-30-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman SHINE Bazaar, Craft Sale on Dec. 3rd

11-30-2016Obituaries
Sonia L. Stephanie

11-30-2016Obituaries
Linda Wolff

11-30-2016Community - Crivitz
Violin Lessons, Bowl New Area Classes

11-30-2016Community - Crivitz
Honored for 70 Years in Catholic Financial

11-30-2016Front Page
21 Volunteers Become Advocates for Children

11-30-2016Community - Wausaukee
Wagner Fire Department Sportsman Raffle Winners

11-30-2016Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee School Earns 3 Stars on Report Cards

11-30-2016Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Students Grades 4-6 in Chess Club

11-30-2016Front Page
Judge Halts Dec. 1 Start Of Overtime/Salary Rule

11-30-2016Front Page
Wisconsin Presidential Recount Is Underway

11-30-2016Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Blood Drive is Dec. 5th

11-30-2016Front Page
Lectures, Tours Offered On Proposed Back Forty Mine

11-30-2016Front Page
Gala Parade, Many Events for Christmas in Marinette Dec. 3

11-30-2016Obituaries
Virginia E. Wilson

11-30-2016Obituaries
Stephen J. Wallace

11-30-2016Obituaries
Gail G. Van Caster

11-30-2016Perspectives
Country Cousin

11-30-2016Perspectives
From My Window

11-30-2016Sports
2 Crivitz Youth Compete in PPK at Green Bay Dec. 4

11-30-2016Sports
Area Girls' Basketball

11-30-2016Sports
Area Boys' Basketball

11-30-2016Sports
MHSAA State Championship

11-22-2016Front Page
Sentinel Structures Trucks Oversized Load of Arches

11-22-2016Front Page
Peshtigo School Board Views Tentative New Building Plans

11-22-2016Front Page
Grover Voters Okay Levy Hike For New Fire Truck

11-22-2016Front Page
Coleman Earns Highest DPI Report Card Rating

11-22-2016Front Page
Wausaukee Residents Urged To Attend Nov. 30 Hearing

11-22-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman SHINE Bazaar, Craft Sale on Dec. 3rd

11-22-2016Community - Coleman
Santa Claus at Village Pound Lights Parade

11-22-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman Trinity Church Advent Meal, Services

11-22-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman Youth Wrestling Sign Up

11-22-2016Community - Crivitz
Church Sponsors Christmas in the Village of Bethlehem

11-22-2016Community - Crivitz
Crivitz 2nd Graders Thank Veterans

11-22-2016Community - Crivitz
Howard Members Join Crivitz VFW Memorial

11-22-2016Community - Crivitz
Loomis Historical Christmas Pot Luck

11-22-2016Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Students Win Legion Auxiliary National Award

11-22-2016Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Booster Club Wine, Beer Testing Feb. 11

11-22-2016Community - Wausaukee
Town of Wausaukee Levy is $445,957.40

11-22-2016Community - Wausaukee
Library Cookie Walk Dec. 3rd

11-22-2016Obituaries
Doris M. Zimmerman

11-22-2016Obituaries
Eugene Trepanier

11-22-2016Obituaries
Patricia L. Thomas

11-22-2016Obituaries
Floyd F. Suennen

11-22-2016Obituaries
Irene D. Strzyzykowski

11-22-2016Obituaries
Evelyn C. Quarnstrom

11-22-2016Obituaries
Harry J. Ruff

11-22-2016Obituaries
Jerry L. Popp

11-22-2016Obituaries
Austin Kubiak

11-22-2016Obituaries
Jane M. Janes

11-22-2016Obituaries
James Haban

11-22-2016Obituaries
Ralph E. Bancroft

11-22-2016Obituaries
Dona J. Van Hoff

11-22-2016Obituaries
David A. McClain

11-22-2016Obituaries
Nick Vidas

11-22-2016Obituaries
Agnes Kowalski

11-22-2016Obituaries
Elsabea J. Oldham

11-22-2016Obituaries
Kenneth W. Westcott

11-22-2016Obituaries
Orville J. Renier

11-22-2016Obituaries
Raymond H. Rakers

11-22-2016Obituaries
The Rev. em. Reginald E. Pope

11-22-2016Obituaries
Albert P. Mineau

11-22-2016Obituaries
Elaine A. Marquardt

11-22-2016Obituaries
Elizabeth J. Lownik

11-22-2016Obituaries
Betty A. LaCount

11-22-2016Obituaries
Doris I. Kriegl

11-22-2016Obituaries
Angeline H. Johnston 

11-22-2016Obituaries
Barbara A. Erickson

11-22-2016Obituaries
Carol M. Bushmaker 

11-22-2016Perspectives
Country Cousin

11-22-2016Perspectives
From our readers

11-22-2016Perspectives
From My Window

11-22-2016Sports
Coach Motkowski Ready to Unleash "Dogs in '16-൙

11-22-2016Sports
M&O Basketball - Area Teams Start Season with Wins

11-22-2016Sports
Young Marines Hold On in Season Opener

11-22-2016Sports
MSHAA Semifinal - Maroons To Face Grand Rapids West In State Final

11-16-2016Obituaries
Rosemary A. Stowick

11-16-2016Obituaries
Deanie A. Simerl

11-16-2016Obituaries
Sam Schomer

11-16-2016Obituaries
Patricia J. Roland  

11-16-2016Obituaries
Robert Race

11-16-2016Obituaries
Melvin A. Olson

11-16-2016Obituaries
Norman F. Lueskow

11-16-2016Obituaries
Betty J. Krull

11-16-2016Obituaries
Margaret M. Kirschbaum

11-16-2016Obituaries
William E. Keller Jr.

11-16-2016Obituaries
Hollister Jansen

11-16-2016Obituaries
Ione Herrmann

11-16-2016Obituaries
Pat Cletus Courchaine

11-16-2016Obituaries
Sandra J. Beekman

11-16-2016Obituaries
Lowell White

11-16-2016Obituaries
Genevieve J. Adamczyk

11-16-2016Obituaries
Shirley M. Walters

11-16-2016Obituaries
Charles H. Antholt

11-16-2016Obituaries
Eleanor E. Peterson

11-16-2016Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Church Pie, Bake Sale

11-16-2016Obituaries
Autumn L. La Londe

11-16-2016Obituaries
Michael C. Kinard

11-16-2016Community - Wausaukee
Klaver's Lawn Care Hired by Athelstane Town Board

11-16-2016Obituaries
Jan DeGayner

11-16-2016Community - Wausaukee
Christmas for Kids Gift Distribution

11-16-2016Community - Wausaukee
Athelstane Craft Fair on Nov. 19

11-16-2016Front Page
Town of Peshtigo Settles Mercury Asssessment

11-16-2016Obituaries
Robert F. Biemeret, Sr.

11-16-2016Front Page
BELLIN OPEN HOUSE

11-16-2016Perspectives
Country Cousin

11-16-2016Community - Crivitz
Free Thanksgiving Dinner at Crivitz

11-16-2016Community - Crivitz
Loomis Legion Fun Day Was Big Success

11-16-2016Community - Crivitz
Loomis Historical Pot Luck Dec. 1

11-16-2016Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Students Top in Studies, Athletics

11-16-2016Community - Coleman
Woman's Club Meets at PK Fit in Coleman

11-16-2016Community - Coleman
Thanksgiving Recess For Coleman School

11-16-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman Youth Wrestling Sign Up

11-16-2016Perspectives
From our readers

11-16-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman Library Mini Auction

11-16-2016Perspectives
From My Window

11-16-2016Sports
Salewski/Christensen Headline First Team Griders

11-16-2016Front Page
Ask City To Consider Vacating Green Street

11-16-2016Sports
Suring's Stegeman Reigns Supreme as Volleyball MVP

11-16-2016Front Page
Peshtigo Police Chief FitzGerald Is Settling In

11-16-2016Sports
MSHAA Playoffs - Menominee Moves onto State Semis With Dominating Win Over Reed City

11-16-2016Sports
WIAA to Crown State Football Champions

11-16-2016Front Page
Coleman School Board Discusses Building Upgrade Referendum

11-09-2016Community - Coleman
Thanksgiving Dinner at Pound Church

11-09-2016Community - Coleman
Equity Bean Bag League To Meet

11-09-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman Students Score Best in Area on 2016 State Assessment

11-09-2016Community - Coleman
Coleman-Pound Restaurants To Honor Area Veterans

11-09-2016Community - Crivitz
Woman's Club Holiday Auction, Boutique Nov. 10

11-09-2016Community - Crivitz
Free Community Thanksgiving Dinner

11-09-2016Community - Crivitz
Female Self-Defense Crivitz Clinic Nov. 12th


space
Peshtigo Times
WEB Poll!
Do you think that a recount is necessary?
space Yes
No
Undecided
space
TO VOTE CLICK
YES, NO or UNDECIDED

Suggest a Question
space .
space
FRONT
space
.
space
CLASSIFIEDS
space
.
space
COMMUNITY
space
.
space
GUEST BOOK
space
.
space
NEWS
space
.
space
OBITS
space
.
space
PERSPECTIVES
space
.
space
SPORTS
space
.
space
SUBSCRIBE
space
.
space
.
space
PESHTIGO FIRE
space
.
space
CUSTOM PRINTING
space
.
space
TIMES' SAVER
space
.
space
Click for Peshtigo, Wisconsin Forecast
FORECAST
space
Quick...
News or Ad Search
Enter News key words.
Enter Ad key words.



Peshtigo Times
841 Maple St
PO Box 187
Peshtigo, WI 54157
Phone: 715-582-4541
Email:
News@
PeshtigoTimes.com

space
Fax: 715-582-4662
© 2000-2016
All right reserved
space
Powered by
WEB Media
Interactive
COMMUNITY
WEB sites