space
space
Peshtigo Times
space
space
space
Perspectives
* Country Cousin
space
space
Sports Shorts
* WIAA Crowns Five Champions at Boys State Hoops Tourney
* Bulldog Baseball Team Ready to Defend Packerland Title
* Area Teams Compete at Oshkosh Indoor Invitational
* WIAA Boys State Basketball to Tip-Off at Kohl Center
* Five Girls Basketball State Titles Decided Saturday at Resch Center

space
Peshtigo Fire
space
e-Edition
Now Available
For more information
click here
dot
THE CITY REBORN FROM THE ASHES OF AMERICA'S MOST DISASTROUS FOREST FIRE
space
dot
space

Environmental Groups Pledge To Continue Back Forty Fight

Issue Date: June 14, 2018

Environmental groups opposed to development of the controversial Aquila Resources Back Forty Mine in Stephenson, Mich. are crying foul over last week's decision by the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) to approve a Wetland Permit for development of the mine near the banks of the Menominee River. Local residents opposed to the mine have pledged that their fight is not over.

In a joint statement, the Mining Action Group (MAG) of the Upper Peninsula Environmental Coalition (UPEC), the Front 40 Environmental Fight, and numerous other local and regional environmental groups say they are outraged by what they claim is an unwarranted approval and are calling on DEQ Director Heidi Grether to explain her decision.

"This smells rotten," declared spokesman Kathleen Heideman. "Director Grether's approval of the Aquila Back Forty Wetland permit was a political act, directly contradicting the recommendation of DEQ's own Water Resources Division. This permit is inconsistent with the clean Water Act!"

She and others said the Wetland permit should have been denied, according to the agency's own "Findings of Fact", and quoted, "After due consideration of the permit application, on-site investigation and review of other pertinent materials, the Water Resources Division finds that the project does NOT demonstrate that an unacceptable disruption to the aquatic resources of the State will not occur and that the activities associated with the project are NOT consistent with the permitting criteria for an acceptable impact to the resources regulated under Parts 301, Inland Lakes and Streams, and Part 303, Wetlands Protection."

Even the DEQ's decision letter is not an endorsement, they said, again quoting: "We have determined that the (Back Forty) project as proposed could not be permitted without additional supporting documentation because the hydrologic modeling provided does not define the anticipated impacts to aquatic resources."

Ron Henriksen, spokesperson for the Front 40 Environmental Fight, said he was stunned. "Against the findings of Water Resources staff, Director Grether of the DEQ granted a permit with 28 pages of "Special Conditions.' Why wasn't this permit denied? The serious hydrological concerns we've raised remain unaddressed. Aquila's mine will harm wetlands of the Menominee River and aquatic resources shared by Michigan and Wisconsin, yet these concerns were somehow overruled. The Menominee River certainly deserves better."

The news release charges that, "Overlooking the application's gaping holes, DEQ issued Aquila's Wetland permit "conditionally' and has required "submission and approval' of key additional information including revised hydrologic modeling, an adaptive management plan, a comprehensive monitoring plan, and requisite wetland and stream mitigation."

There were comments that under the Clean Water Act this information must be provided before a wetland destruction permit is granted, not after, and accurate hydrologic modeling, monitoring, and compensatory mitigation based on real data are the foundational requirements of a wetland permit application, not special permit conditions. Steve Garske of the Mining Action Group said by law, Aquila should have provided this information at least two years ago.

Opponents say the application suggests that if impact exceeds estimates the mine operators can simply pump water from the Menominee River into the wetlands.

They accused Grether of making a hasty political decision and ignoring the independent reports commissioned by anti-mine groups and repeated contentions that the Back Forty mine "is a disaster in the making."

They cited EPA objections in a March 8, 2018 letter to the Michigan DEQ: "The applicant has not provided a complete description of the project, including a final site plan identifying the final location of key project features, including storm water and waste management features. The proposed site layout is not consistent with the approved state Permit to Mine. Nor are all impacts of the project identified in the application, including impacts caused by any planned underground mining, a power plant, and mining water management systems. Without this information, the reviewing agencies cannot adequately assess the extent of the proposed mine's impact on aquatic resources as required by the CWA, and or determine whether the applicant has minimized and avoided aquatic resource impacts, as required."

They go on to say that the EPA letter pointed out that while Aquila states that the project will not adversely affect water quality of the Menominee River they do not explain how the project will be managed to ensure discharges will meet water quality standards, including sufficient monitoring locations, minimization measures, and adaptive management procedures to prevent leaching of toxic compounds from mine storage facilities and from the mine pit into the River.

The release states the EPA found the application "lacks information regarding the extent of wetlands that will be impacted by the project and how these wetlands will be affected by the proposed project's Menominee River drawdown of some 125,000 gallons per day," and directed the DEQ to resolve those and other concerns within 90 days or deny the permit for the mine, and then the permit was issued although the DEQ and Aquila did not resolve these concerns.

Garske said there is no finalized site plan or acknowledgement of planned underground mining facilities, no approved plan to prevent leaching of toxins into the Menominee River, no accurate hydrological model for the mine site, and the Back Forty wetland impacts remain unknown, and added, "The federal objections were mysteriously rescinded," and described the decision as "a stunning example of big-money politics taking precedence over the public good."

"I'd like to say I was surprised by the approval of the Back 40's wetland permit, but actually was not," said Deb Skubal of the Front 40 anti mine group. "This whole outcome is consistent with how the DEQ has operated thus far.  The Director went so far as to write "the project as proposed could not be permitted without additional supporting documentation".

Heideman described Aquila's Wetland permit as "" the most inept, shoddy heap of paperwork I've ever seen. When the permit is held up to the light of legal scrutiny, light will shine in through a thousand holes!"

"A sulfide mine on the shores of the Menominee River endangers the health and way of life of the entire region to profit a foreign owned corporation. Michigan DEQ's approval of the wetland permit an injustice to all of us," declared Raj Shukla, Executive Director of the River Alliance of Wisconsin.

"I pray for the wild rice people while I take note of the names of each and every federal and state official approving every single aspect of this 800 foot deep open pit mine less than 100 feet from the great Menominee River. Every single one of them must be held accountable when this fails and harms the fishery, the drinking water for millions of people and more. Accountability is a predominate conservative principal. They must all be held accountable in full measure," said Jeffery Loman of the L'Anse Indian Reservation.

"DEQ's approval of the wetlands permit obviously ignored the opposition to this mine by thousands of people. Why were we ignored?" asked Dick Dragiewicz, who describes himself as an avid Menominee River fisherman.

"This certainly is not the end of our opposition; it is the resurrection of government 'of the people, for the people, and by the people.'  We stand united with organizations all across the state of Wisconsin and Michigan, and we are in it for the long haul," promised Dale Burie, of Wagner, president of the Coalition to Save the Menominee River, Inc.

Carl Lindquist, Executive Director of Superior Watershed Partnership and Land Trust (SWP), said: "The fact that eight Native American tribes have fought this mine should have been enough. Or the fact that the Menominee River was selected as one of the ten most endangered rivers in America. Or the amount of local opposition. An open pit mine on the edge of a river that flows directly into the Great Lakes - SWP staff can't imagine a worse location."

Bob Allison, deputy director of Michigan League of Conservation Voters, said the DEQ approval "" represents yet another fundamental failure by the agency to safeguard Michigan's precious water resources. We continue to see the DEQ give preference to polluting industries, in this case allowing a mining company to make fortunes while polluting the pristine waters of the Upper Peninsula. The impact of this reckless decision will be felt for generations, with negative impacts on waterways in both Michigan and Wisconsin."


Recent stories, opinions and photos

Issue Date Department Headline
03-21-2019Obituaries
Becky S. Butterfield

03-21-2019Obituaries
Shirley A. Farley

03-21-2019Obituaries
Michael C. Frewerd

03-21-2019Obituaries
Martha Harth

03-21-2019Obituaries
Milton C. Heiden

03-21-2019Obituaries
Kathy J. Hopp

03-21-2019Obituaries
Mary C. Huempfner

03-21-2019Obituaries
Justina A. Johanek

03-21-2019Obituaries
Jane L. Kipp

03-21-2019Obituaries
Ilene I. Koebach

03-21-2019Obituaries
Rebecca J. Konyn

03-21-2019Obituaries
William J. Legault

03-21-2019Obituaries
Robert S. Ondik

03-21-2019Obituaries
Dennis G. Schroeder

03-21-2019Obituaries
Gerald K. Stoltenow

03-21-2019Obituaries
Edna Thorpe

03-21-2019Front Page
Magdalene Tisch

03-21-2019Obituaries
Nancy A. Tisler

03-21-2019Obituaries
Richard F. Versailles

03-21-2019Obituaries
Dorothea J. Wunderlich

03-21-2019Obituaries
Carol J. Yuenger

03-21-2019Sports
WIAA Crowns Five Champions at Boys State Hoops Tourney

03-21-2019
M&M Thunder Cap Season With 3rd Place State Finish

03-21-2019Sports
Bulldog Baseball Team Ready to Defend Packerland Title

03-21-2019Sports
Area Teams Compete at Oshkosh Indoor Invitational

03-21-2019Perspectives
Country Cousin

03-21-2019Perspectives
From My Window

03-21-2019Perspectives
From our readers

03-21-2019Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee School "Bring Parents Day" March 29

03-21-2019Community - Wausaukee
Easter Egg Hunt Is April 20th

03-21-2019Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Lion's Host Bowl Tourney

03-21-2019Community - Wausaukee
Lions Annual Flower Sale

03-21-2019Community - Crivitz
Drawdown at Caldron Falls Dam For Spring Thaw

03-21-2019Community - Crivitz
Sip For a Cause, Quilt Show Apr. 4

03-21-2019Community - Crivitz
Mental Health Wellness Conference at Crivitz Apr. 13

03-21-2019Community - Crivitz
Loomis Historical Meets April 4

03-21-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman High School Wins Academic Bowl

03-21-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman DAR Award Recipient

03-21-2019Community - Coleman
Easter Event at Coleman April 20

03-21-2019Community - Coleman
Ribbon Cutting for New coleman Business

03-21-2019Front Page
Suspect Jailed For 1976 McClintock Park Murders

03-21-2019Front Page
Body Found In Menominee River Identified, Arrest Made

03-21-2019Front Page
Town Of Peshtigo Hires Consultant

03-21-2019Front Page
Goldschmidt, Meyhoff Are Not Candidates For Wagner Board

03-21-2019Front Page
County Board Expected To OK Laura Frea For Dist. 14

03-15-2019Community - Wausaukee
Beecher Board Hears Reports and Variance

03-15-2019
Lions Annual Flower Sale

03-15-2019Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Lion's Host Bowl Tourney

03-15-2019Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Ski Cats Host Crivitz Classic

03-15-2019Community - Crivitz
CPR Class at Bellin in Crivitz Mar. 27

03-15-2019Community - Coleman
Pound Assembly Sponsors Wellness Conference Mar. 23

03-15-2019Community - Coleman
Craft, Vendor Show at Equity Hall Mar. 30

03-15-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman School Gets $3500 Grant

03-15-2019Sports
WIAA Boys State Basketball to Tip-Off at Kohl Center

03-15-2019Sports
Five Girls Basketball State Titles Decided Saturday at Resch Center

03-15-2019Sports
Peshtigo River Bowhunters Hold Annual Awards Banquet

03-15-2019Sports
Maroon Girls Stand Strong With 3 Post Season Wins

03-15-2019Perspectives
From our readers

03-15-2019Perspectives
Country Cousin National Pi Day"

03-15-2019Perspectives
From My Window Shelter Friends

03-15-2019Obituaries
Patricia A. Zimmerman

03-15-2019Obituaries
Richard Versailles

03-15-2019Obituaries
William B. Reabe

03-15-2019Obituaries
Martin Lake

03-15-2019Obituaries
Donald C. Kuffel

03-15-2019Obituaries
Russell A. Kanerva

03-15-2019Obituaries
Eugene R. Hudson

03-15-2019Obituaries
Brian F. Hafeman

03-15-2019Obituaries
Ron Dembroski

03-15-2019Obituaries
Pamela M. Bramschreiber

03-15-2019Obituaries
Susan L. Boettcher

03-15-2019Obituaries
Jeffery J. Anglehart

03-15-2019Obituaries
Gerald V. Walk

03-15-2019Obituaries
Virginia Mae Tackmier

03-15-2019Obituaries
Raymond D. Sparr

03-15-2019Obituaries
Michael F. Prokash

03-15-2019Obituaries
Grace L. Phillips

03-15-2019Obituaries
Betty D. Devine

03-15-2019Obituaries
Richard L. Tebo

03-15-2019Obituaries
Jeffrey S. Reitz

03-15-2019Obituaries
Dolores Mary Pfeiff  

03-15-2019Obituaries
Helen M. Peters

03-15-2019Obituaries
Jewel M. Pennington

03-15-2019Obituaries
Janice L. Millering

03-15-2019Obituaries
John M. Miller

03-15-2019Obituaries
A. Beverly Kaatz

03-15-2019
Marion G. Hutson

03-15-2019Obituaries
Audrey M. Cleary

03-15-2019Front Page
Wagner Has Two New Write In Candidates

03-15-2019Front Page
Peshtigo School District Hires Howick Associates

03-15-2019Front Page
Middle Inlet May Sell Pines Road Fire Station

03-15-2019Front Page
Sump Pumps Must Not Drain Into Sanitary Sewers

03-07-2019Obituaries
Gerald F. Beyer

03-07-2019Obituaries
Thomas M. Bourgeois

03-07-2019Obituaries
Tracy L. Brendemihl

03-07-2019Obituaries
Gwen Lynn Broeder

03-07-2019Obituaries
Katherine M. Buchner

03-07-2019Obituaries
James E. Buelteman 

03-07-2019Obituaries
Verona M. Carlson

03-07-2019Obituaries
Andrew Chiesa

03-07-2019Obituaries
Ethel Fredrick

03-07-2019Obituaries
Rodney J. Glover

03-07-2019
Michele M. Harris

03-07-2019Obituaries
Alyce G. Hinz

03-07-2019Obituaries
Les Jones

03-07-2019Obituaries
Lynn A. Kitzinger

03-07-2019Obituaries
Sharon L. Kowalkowski

03-07-2019Obituaries
Elmer J. Magnuson

03-07-2019Obituaries
Thomas Malke

03-07-2019Obituaries
Glen E. Malloy

03-07-2019Obituaries
Joan E. Miller

03-07-2019Obituaries
Linda L. Nerat

03-07-2019Obituaries
Gerald D. Paris

03-07-2019Obituaries
Gerald J. Payette.

03-07-2019Obituaries
Edward Roeder

03-07-2019Obituaries
JaRon D. Scearce

03-07-2019Obituaries
Corrine C. Schroeder

03-07-2019Obituaries
Joyce L. Schroeder

03-07-2019Obituaries
Patricia A. Shatusky

03-07-2019Obituaries
Joyce Steinbrecher

03-07-2019Obituaries
Katharine Trinkl

03-07-2019
Sharon Weed

03-07-2019
Susan J. Wetthuhn

03-07-2019Obituaries
Roger G. Wickman

03-07-2019Obituaries
Mary A. Wills

03-07-2019Sports
Bulldog Boys Bowling Team Takes Bronze at State Tourney

03-07-2019Sports
Thunder Skate to Silver in WCHSHL Tournament

03-07-2019Sports
Rangers Defeat Tigers/Fall To Newman in Sectionals

03-07-2019Sports
Peshtigo/Suring Lose Regional Final Heartbreakers

03-07-2019Perspectives
Country Cousin

03-07-2019Perspectives
From My Window

03-07-2019Perspectives
From our readers

03-07-2019Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Town Board Gets "State of the School"

03-07-2019Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Lion's 9 Pin Tournament

03-07-2019Community - Wausaukee
St. Augustine Lenten Fish Fries

03-07-2019Community - Wausaukee
Silver Cliff Lists Card Party Winners

03-07-2019Community - Crivitz
Legion Plans for June 29 Run

03-07-2019Community - Crivitz
Middle Inlet Fire Department Officially Joins MABAS

03-07-2019Community - Crivitz
NewCare Topic of Mar. 11 Talk

03-07-2019Community - Crivitz
Sip For a Cause, Quilt Show Apr. 4

03-07-2019Community - Coleman
Broderick Seeks Pound Town Supervisor Post

03-07-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman School District to Meet March 11th

03-07-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman Water Sewer Committee to Meet

03-07-2019Community - Coleman
Wellness Conference At Pound Hillside

03-07-2019Front Page
Peshtigo City Council Puts Plans For Fish Viewing Platform Back On Track

03-07-2019Front Page
Tyco Hosting Open House On Groundwater Issues

03-07-2019Front Page
Marinette Public Works Rejects Street Bids

03-07-2019Front Page
Pound Seeks Volunteers For Parade Committee

03-07-2019Front Page
Coleman Welcomes New Businesses

02-28-2019Obituaries
Eugene R. Bellow


space
Peshtigo Times
WEB Poll!
Do you think Nancy Pelosi is doing a good job as Speaker of the House?
space Yes
No
Undecided
space
TO VOTE CLICK
YES, NO or UNDECIDED

Suggest a Question
space .
space
FRONT
space
.
space
CLASSIFIEDS
space
.
space
COMMUNITY
space
.
space
GUEST BOOK
space
.
space
NEWS
space
.
space
OBITS
space
.
space
PERSPECTIVES
space
.
space
SPORTS
space
.
space
SUBSCRIBE
space
.
space
.
space
PESHTIGO FIRE
space
.
space
CUSTOM PRINTING
space
.
space
TIMES' SAVER
space
.
space
Click for Peshtigo, Wisconsin Forecast
FORECAST
space
Quick...
News or Ad Search
Enter News key words.
Enter Ad key words.



Peshtigo Times
841 Maple St
PO Box 187
Peshtigo, WI 54157
Phone: 715-582-4541
Email:
News@
PeshtigoTimes.com

space
Fax: 715-582-4662
© 2000-2019
All right reserved
space
Powered by
WEB Media
Interactive
COMMUNITY
WEB sites